TurboTax vs H&R Block: Which One is Really Cheaper?

They both promise “Free Filing,” but we all know the drill: you get to the end, and suddenly it costs $120. We compared the hidden fees of the top tax software so you don’t get ripped off.

BMT Product Review Team BMT Product Review Team · 📅 Jan 2026 · ⏱️ 5 min read · TAX TIPS › SOFTWARE
TurboTax
$$$
Best UXEasy
H&R Block
$$
Better ValueValue
FreeTaxUSA
$15
The UnderdogCheap

The “Real” Cost Comparison

Ignore the “Free” ads. Here is what you will actually pay if you are a homeowner or have a side hustle (Freelance).

Software Deluxe (Home) Premium (Freelance)
TurboTax $69 + $59 (State) $129 + $64
H&R Block $55 + $49 (State) $85 + $49
FreeTaxUSA $0 + $15 (State) $0 + $15
Cash App $0 (Totally Free) $0
Hidden Fee Warning
Both TurboTax and H&R Block charge extra (approx $40) if you choose to pay the filing fee out of your refund instead of using a credit card. Always pay with a card upfront!
Value for Money
TurboTax UX 9.5/10
Super easy. Idiot-proof.
H&R Block UX 8.5/10
Solid, slightly clunkier.
FreeTaxUSA UX 7.0/10
Basic forms. No fancy help.
User TypeWinner
First TimerTurboTax
Cost SaverFreeTaxUSA

Detailed Breakdown

TurboTax: The “Premium” Choice

If you have crypto investments or day trade stocks, TurboTax is the best. It connects directly to Coinbase and Robinhood to import thousands of trades instantly. It saves hours of typing.
Verdict: Pay the premium if your taxes are messy.

H&R Block: The “Hybrid” Choice

H&R Block is great if you are nervous. Why? Because if you get stuck online, you can pay extra to have a human in a local office finish it for you.
Verdict: Good middle ground.

FreeTaxUSA: The “Budget” King

It does the exact same math as TurboTax. It just doesn’t have the pretty animations or “Live Help.” If you know what a W-2 is, use this and save $100.
Verdict: Best for anyone confident with basic forms.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Cash App Taxes really free?
Yes. It is 100% free for federal and state. But it is mobile-focused and can be annoying to use for complex returns.
Why does TurboTax charge me?
They use a “Freemium” model. Simple returns are free, but the moment you upload a Health Savings Account (HSA) or Unemployment form, they force you to upgrade to Deluxe.